jthrash's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[Comm for someone's friend]

Very pretty! I'm even more serious now that your art style could probably get you a job at Disney!

And speaking of concept art--yeah, I've noticed you and others have had to make the unfortunate decision to start watermarking everything you post so that, at the very least, AI art scraping algorithms don't get the highest quality version of your work, but the watermark does seem to have a good balance of being clearly there while not ruining the entire picture too much. If anything, I almost want the watermark to be a smidge more opaque so I can fully read what it says!

Catinyt responds:

thank you so much!!
also, I started using this watermark not 'cause the Ia'S STUFF, BUT BECAUSE SOME PEEPS STARTED USING THE COMMISSIONS I DID FOR OTHER PEEPS AS PFPS :(
ALSO IT JUST SAYS "COMMISSION, DONT USE IT PLEASE" I THINK I HAVE TO FIN ANOTHER WAY TO MAKE IT MORE READABLE? XD
ALSO SORRY FOR ALL THESE CAPITAL SENTENCES, I DONT WANT TO SCREAM AT YOU, LOL

[my odst drawing!]

The top half is fantastic, but it looks like you ran out of energy in the bottom half. Still, the top half is absolutely STUNNING! Keep trying, you clearly have some great potential based on that top half alone (drools at the details)!

gothicseawitch responds:

thanks! i did get tired, my neck hurt for starring all the details down and my nerves where hurting at the end.

[Bloom Lordmon]

This is what happens when you are both the most "alpha" of males and also greatly in touch with your feminine side!

[meeting]

Man, Pim from Smiling Friends got swole!

[Gift - Suika]

At this point, those breasts could function as 3rd and 4th arms!

[Warmup - Star Wars a new hope]

This is actually terrifying to look at, more so than what was possible in live action in 1979!

[Ms. Notabot 123 (As Teacher)]

I hate to be that one guy who makes a critique after all this praise you're getting, but one thing you may want to watch out for in future background drawings is not having lines too close to each other (I'm sorry if I can't remember what my college professors called this). Basically, in this case, to make it more obvious that the chair bottom is closer to us than the book case in perspective, it would help if the chair bottom extends past the bookcase. It looks like the vertical line on the chair almost perfectly touches the vertical edge of the book case, and I guess it makes it look like the chair bottom is flat?

Man, I need to look up that term my professors used so I don't have to explain this in so many words. Either way, this drawing is very entertaining and great overall, I just wanted to help a little bit to make future stuff look even better!

Finasty responds:

Now i understand what you mean, the bookcase is a bit far from the chair in case of perspective, that's why you see the vertical lines almost touched perfectly

[Public U. Art Club #8]

Shen finally figures out that if you want to get tons of praise (and money) on the Internet, you need to draw cute girls doing cute things!

Regardless, even if they were hideous monstrosities like what Potatoman tends to make (the best way to get tons of praise and money from me, quite honestly) I am genuinely fascinated to see where this story will go every week and so glad it wasn't a one-off gag comic, or even ended with just the AI art jokes! Best way to ring in 2023, reading a surprisingly-amazing indie comic!

[Sketch Saturday, returns]

That image at the end cracked me up! Though I've seen straight women who actually look like that, they just tend to gather muscle and fat mostly in their upper body, so I don't know if Trixie is supposed to be a genderswap or simply very top-heavy!